Results Are In – The Reality of Being a Manager Today

Well, it’s out – The 2024 Global Managers Survey, conducted by Circle In in April 2024, surveyed 1,022 managers from organisations worldwide, with more than 50% of respondents working in companies with over 500 employees. The study aimed to explore the challenges faced by managers in supporting their teams, particularly around mental health and wellbeing, in an era marked by increased stress, burnout, and complex personal situations.

The survey revealed key insights into how managers are handling emotional support, mental health issues, and major life events within their teams, while also highlighting the need for better organisational support and training for managers.

I’ve been touting this for many years, and these findings underscore it – it is so important that we upskill managers.  All too often we promote technically great people into management and leadership roles and then leave them to it!  It’s not good enough.

Let’s have a look at some of the key trends and findings from the Survey and I’ve added in some potential initiatives that organisations might think about (mostly from the point of view of a Mental Health First Aid Officers Network (MHFAON) but you can replace MHFAON with Organisation):

Summary of Key Trends and Potential Initiatives for Improvement

1. Stress and Burnout
Key Trends:
  • 75% of managers report experiencing stress and burnout, with the volume of support provided to teams increasing or staying the same over the past 12 months.
  • 70% of managers say providing emotional support to their team impacts their own stress levels.
  • 34% of managers have supported a team member through burnout.

What Can We Do?

  • Peer Support Circles: Organise regular peer support groups or check-ins where employees can share experiences and coping strategies in a confidential, supportive environment.
  • Workload Awareness Programs: Raise awareness about workload management and burnout prevention through workshops on stress management and workplace wellbeing.
  • Mental Health Days: Advocate for flexible leave policies that allow employees to take mental health days, and ensure that these are normalised and supported within the workplace.
2. Support for Major Life Events
Key Trend:
  • 70% of managers have supported a team member through major life events such as grief, illness, family violence, separation, or fertility issues.
  • Supporting employees during these times is seen as a major part of a manager’s role, with 90% of managers acknowledging the importance of this support.

What Can We Do?

  • Specialised Support for Life Events: Train MHFAOs to provide emotional support and guidance to staff facing major life events like grief, illness, or family issues.
  • Resource Referrals: Set up a system where MHFAOs can refer employees to appropriate professional support services, such as counselling or external mental health services.
  • Awareness Campaigns: Raise awareness around common life events and their impacts on mental health, and distribute resources on coping strategies or mental health care.
3. Mental Health Support
Key Trend:
  • 60% of managers have supported a team member with anxiety, depression, or mental health issues.
  • Managers need to be better equipped to handle mental health challenges, and effective training is essential for better supporting staff.

What Can We Do?

  • Mental Health First Aid Refresher Courses: Offer regular refresher training sessions for MHFAOs to ensure they are up-to-date with the latest mental health support practices and techniques.
  • Safe Spaces: Create confidential “safe spaces” where employees can speak to a trained MHFAO about their mental health struggles without fear of stigma or judgment.
  • Mental Health Awareness Campaigns: Run initiatives to reduce stigma around mental health, such as “Mental Health Awareness Weeks,” where MHFAOs can lead discussions, share resources, and provide mental health support strategies.
4. Workload and Wellbeing
Key Trend:
  • 52% of managers have supported a team member with issues related to excessive workload.
  • Excessive workload is a significant contributor to stress and burnout.
  • Prolonged heavy workloads can negatively affect employee wellbeing and productivity.

What Can We Do?

  • Workload Assessments:  Managers and Leaders need to work with their teams to identify employees who may be struggling with excessive workload and offer additional support.
  • Time Management Workshops: Organise workshops on time management, prioritisation, and setting healthy boundaries at work.
  • Encouraging Regular Breaks: Promote the importance of regular breaks, including “mental health breaks,” to reduce stress and improve overall productivity.
5. Lack of Organisational Support
Key Trend:
  • 62% of managers feel inadequately supported by their organisations.
  • This gap in support highlights the need for organisations to invest in leadership training for managers to prevent burnout and improve overall wellbeing.

What Can We Do?

  • Wellbeing Champions: Establish wellbeing champions within teams who can advocate for mental health support and ensure that employees feel heard and supported.
  • Feedback Loops: Create a confidential feedback system, allowing MHFAOs to collect employee concerns and suggestions regarding wellbeing, and ensure these are communicated to leadership.
  • Employee Assistance Program (EAP) Promotion: Actively promote the use of available EAPs or other mental health resources, ensuring staff are aware of and comfortable accessing them.
6. Empathy and Effective Leadership
Key Trend:
  • Empathy is crucial for effective leadership.
  • Managers who demonstrate empathy foster a more innovative, committed, and inclusive workplace.
  • Managers who are trained in empathy see improved employee engagement, better performance, and enhanced organisational morale.

What Can We Do?

  • Empathy Training: Offer workshops or lunch-and-learns on the importance of empathy in leadership, led by MHFAOs, using real-life scenarios and practical examples.
  • Manager Support Networks: Develop support groups where leaders are provided with guidance on how to effectively manage and support teams, particularly during times of stress or personal challenges.
  • Mastering 1:1 Conversations:  In my view, the most important skill and task of any manager or leader.  I have a short and sharp session on Mastering 1:1 Conversations that not only provides tools and strategies, but is based around the Psychosocial Code of Practice so it’s covering all bases.  You’ll also walk out with brandable templates to use across the organisation.  Download the information here.
  • Empathy in Action: MHFAOs can lead by example, demonstrating empathetic behaviours in their daily interactions and encouraging leaders to do the same, to promote a supportive work environment.

I know there’s a lot on your plate, and many competing priorities vying for your attention. But the reality is, mental health and wellbeing can no longer be something we push to the backburner. This isn’t going to go away on its own and sweeping it under the rug will only make it worse. The time to take action is now, not just for today but for the long-term health of your team and organisation.

If you’re serious about supporting your leaders and managers, I encourage you to have a look at my Leadership Essentials Suite. These short, focused 2-hour sessions—available face to face or online—are designed to support and develop your leaders with practical strategies they can implement immediately. The sessions are a hit because they value participants’ time and provide actionable tools that drive results.

Let’s prioritise the wellbeing of our leaders, and in turn, our teams and organisations. Contact me today to talk about Leadership Essentials and to see how we can work together to support your leaders and managers.  You can download the Leadership Essentials Suite information here.

Everything counts.

Written by Michelle McFadyen

Free eBook

Have you taken the time to really think about what your core values are? Here’s a free eBook designed to help you do just that.

6 Steps to Defining your Core Values

eBook cover

Simply input your details and download my eBook for free. You will also be susbcribed to my mailing list to keep you posted on the latest insights and inspiration. No spam, a newsletter monthly at most. I look forward to connecting with you.

Stay Inspired & Informed

Subscribe for expert insights on leadership, workplace wellbeing, and personal growth, along with practical tools to help you thrive. Join a community dedicated to creating meaningful change—one step at a time. No spam, just a monthly dose of value and inspiration. I can’t wait to connect with you.

Subscribe

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top