Stop Asking Crap Questions – How Smart Leaders Unlock Real Insight

Let’s be honest, leadership is full of landmines. And one of the most common traps leaders fall into is this: jumping straight into fix-it mode before asking the right questions.

We race to “solutions” without even knowing what the real problem is. We tick the decision-making box without exploring what’s beneath the surface. We call it being “efficient.” But often, it’s just panic dressed up as productivity.

Here’s the truth: the quality of your leadership is directly tied to the quality of your questions.

But not just any questions – a rich mix of the right ones.

And no, I’m not talking about your run-of-the-mill open-ended “how do you feel about that?” kind of question. I’m talking about a leadership-level skill: the ability to ask targeted, layered, and insightful questions that cut through confusion and spark the kind of clarity that shifts teams, unlocks ideas, and averts disasters.

Why Your Questioning Style Could Be Killing Innovation (and Morale)

When leaders default to surface-level or reactive questions, or worse, don’t ask any at all, here’s what happens:

  • Psychological safety tanks. People stop offering feedback or ideas.
  • Time and resources are wasted solving the wrong problem.
  • Innovation flatlines because no one is challenging assumptions.

Instead of leading like a firestarter of insight and engagement, you become… well, a firefighter. Constantly dousing spot fires you could’ve prevented with better diagnosis.

Let’s change that.

The 5 Question Types That Separate Great Leaders from the Rest

Strategy professor Arnaud Chevallier (IMD Business School) and his co-researchers identified five core question types used by top-performing leaders around the world. I’ve taken their model and given it a real-world, in-the-trenches leadership twist – with scripts, metaphors, and next steps you can actually use.

1. Investigative Questions – What’s Known?

Think of these as your magnifying glass moments. You’re digging in. Getting forensic. Clarifying what’s real versus what’s noise.

Use these when:

  • The issue is unclear
  • Emotions are running high
  • You suspect you’re only hearing the tip of the iceberg

Examples & Scripts:

  • “What’s the actual problem we’re trying to solve here?”
  • “What do we know for sure? What’s assumption?”
  • “What’s not working – and why?”

Pro tip: Ask “why?” five times like a persistent toddler. It’s annoying. But it works.

2. Speculative Questions – What If?

These are your possibility questions – they kick open the door to innovation. Use them when your team is stuck in linear, same-old thinking.

Use these when:

  • You’re brainstorming
  • You want to break assumptions
  • The team keeps offering the same tired solutions

Examples & Scripts:

  • “What if we had no budget constraints?”
  • “What would we try if failure wasn’t a factor?”
  • “If we had to solve this in 24 hours, what would we do?”

Visual metaphor: Think of these questions like a gust of wind clearing the fog.

3. Productive Questions – Now What?

These are the gear-shift questions. They help you sense if it’s time to hit the accelerator or the brakes.

Use these when:

  • A decision’s been dragging on
  • People are stuck in analysis-paralysis
  • There’s momentum, but no direction

Examples & Scripts:

  • “Do we know enough to take action?”
  • “What’s the minimum viable decision we can make today?”
  • “What would move us forward now without perfect certainty?”

Hot tip: Don’t confuse movement with progress. These questions help you check both.

4. Interpretative Questions – So, What…?

This is where your leadership earns its stripes. Sense-making. Alignment. Finding the story in the data.

Use these when:

  • New information has come to light
  • You’re regrouping after a pivot
  • You need to connect the dots

Examples & Scripts:

  • “So what does this mean for our broader goal?”
  • “What patterns are emerging here?”
  • “How might this change the way we show up as a team?”

Visual metaphor: You’re the compass now. Not the map. Help your team navigate meaning, not just facts.

5. Subjective Questions – What’s Unsaid?

Here’s where most leaders fall short. The real feelings. The politics. The quiet concerns no one wants to name. You need to ask the questions that create space for what’s really going on.

Use these when:

  • Tension is high
  • You’re sensing resistance or discomfort
  • The Team are “yes-ing” you… but something feels off

Examples & Scripts:

  • “What’s your gut saying about this?”
  • “What’s not being said here that we probably need to hear?”
  • “Are there any doubts or tensions we’re glossing over?”

Reminder: You’re not managing robots. You’re leading humans. Ask like it.

Make This Real: How to Use These in Your Next Meeting

  • Audit your current style. Are you mostly asking “What should we do next?” Productive questions are great, but you’re missing the other four.
  • Create a go-to list. Keep a cheat sheet with 2-3 questions from each category. Use it like a leadership Swiss army knife.
  • Use question ’rounds’ in meetings. Try this: one round of investigative questions, one of speculative, one of subjective – before making decisions.
  • Practice the pause. When you feel the urge to solve, just stop. Ask a better question instead.

Your Leadership Action Plan

Download my free Better Questions Cheat Sheet for Leaders here.

Want help embedding this into your leadership team or culture? Contact me to talk about what I can do to support you.

Everything Counts.

Written by Michelle McFadyen.

Free eBook

Have you taken the time to really think about what your core values are? Here’s a free eBook designed to help you do just that.

6 Steps to Defining your Core Values

eBook cover

Simply input your details and download my eBook for free. You will also be susbcribed to my mailing list to keep you posted on the latest insights and inspiration. No spam, a newsletter monthly at most. I look forward to connecting with you.

Stay Inspired & Informed

Subscribe for expert insights on leadership, workplace wellbeing, and personal growth, along with practical tools to help you thrive. Join a community dedicated to creating meaningful change—one step at a time. No spam, just a monthly dose of value and inspiration. I can’t wait to connect with you.

Subscribe

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top